Close Menu
LifePositive
    What's Hot

    Surya Namaskar (Sun Salutation): 12 Steps, Benefits and Safety Tips

    November 13, 2026

    Yoga for Agya Chakra: 7 Poses for Focus and Inner Awareness

    November 3, 2026

    Yoga for Anahata Chakra: 7 Heart-Opening Poses

    November 3, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    • Demos
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
    Tuesday, November 17
    LifePositive
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
    • Wellness
      • Mental Health
      • Healing
      • Nutrition & Healthy Eating
    • Meditation
    • Spirituality
    • Yoga
    • Personal Growth
    • Free Tarot
    • Environment
    • Banyan Tree
    • Other Categories
      • Alternative Therapies
      • Cure
      • Divine
      • Freedom
      • Healthcare Management
      • Holistic Health
      • Inspiration
      • Knowledge
      • Lifestyle
      • Metaphysical Sciences
      • Motivational
      • Parenting
      • Positive Journalism
      • Positivity
      • Spiritual Healing
      • Success Stories
      • Workplace Wellness
    LifePositive
    • Home
    Home - Articles2 - No path No sadhana No guru
    Personal Growth

    No path No sadhana No guru

    Life PositiveBy Life PositiveAugust 18, 2026Updated:November 6, 2026No Comments3 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    August 2010

    By Parthiv N Parekh

    Attempting to deconstruct the teachings of J Krishnamurti


    (A reader sent this piece in response to the interview with Rajesh Dalal in the July 2010 issue: We are afraid to be stripped)

    When it comes to existential reality I feel there is no limit to my confusion or cluelessness. Hence, I am left with no choice but to write from my level of experience and understanding.

    And it is this, precisely, which is also at the root of my bone of contention with the teachings of J Krishnamurti and others such as Rajesh Dalal (featured in the July issue of Life Positive). Their message that no path, sadhana, or guru is needed to realise the ultimate, may well be existentially true. But it is also existentially true, we have been told, that matter does not exist. Yet human beings, including seekers, are firmly entrenched in matter.

    So, of what use are these truisms to seekers for whom they are not a living experience? To them, Krishnamurti’s teaching sounds as futile as that of a massively built body-builder telling a weakling that all he has to do to lift 300 pounds of weight is to bend down and pick it up: “See? Bend down. Grab. Pick-up. Now you do it!” Absurd?

    It is no different when it comes to advice on non-doing. It seems to ignore the fact that different human beings are at different stages of evolution. Why then a blanket admonishment that nothing be done? It seems to negate the lifetimes of karmic structures that don’t allow most seekers to just be. Can a juggernaut as unspeakably complex as transcending the limitless creation be resolved without massive human application? Can it and should it be left to the meager resources of one’s own puny self? Is it not better to be open and available to help from creation itself? Help in the form of a guru and a path and a process?

    So when non-doing is preached, why does the preacher ignore the lifetimes worth of doing that may have gone into bringing them to the place of non-doing?

    What is it that these teachers see that I can’t, which prevents them from saying, “Do what you must–sadhanas, paths, and gurus – and eventually you will come to a place where none of these are needed, and in fact, are impediments.”? But is even that needed to be said? Why, in the first place, teach that which one day will become self-evident, but which, till then, is meaningless, and may be even counterproductive?

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
    Previous ArticleHealing of the soul
    Next Article Winds of change
    Life Positive
    • Website

    Add A Comment
    TRENDING POST

    Surya Namaskar (Sun Salutation): 12 Steps, Benefits and Safety Tips

    November 13, 2026

    Yoga for Agya Chakra: 7 Poses for Focus and Inner Awareness

    November 3, 2026

    Yoga for Anahata Chakra: 7 Heart-Opening Poses

    November 3, 2026

    When the Search Within Becomes a Way of Life

    September 26, 2026

    When the Mind Finds Stillness: The Healing Power of Meditation

    September 26, 2026

    Search of a Spiritual Scientist: Journey of a Scientist Self-Realisation

    September 26, 2026

    A-32, 2nd Floor, Mohan Co-operative Industrial Estate, Mathura Road, New Delhi-110044

    +91 – 11 – 49563721

    info@lifepositive.net

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    Menu
    • Meditation
    • Spirituality
    • Yoga
    • Personal Growth
    • Health
    • Environment
    • Free Tarot
    Useful Links
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Us
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Returns and Refunds Policy
    • Home
    © 2026 LifePositive

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.